Evolution of the "Rock Crusher"
I built my first homebrew linear amplifier in
1968 as a new ham who dreamed of
power and who attended college on the
side. It was a lowly pair of 813's in grounded grid
laying horizontally. It looked nice
and I prided myself in being able to
put those puny SB200's and 30L1's to shame. From then
on I was hooked on the power game. I soon got a
respectable offer on the 813's
(which had grown to three) and sold it.
I also developed a respect for high voltage having got
my fingers into the 1200vac on the
secondary of the plate transformer and having been shocked so
bad I couldn't bend my arm for half
an hour. Free parts were pouring in and it was time
for the "Rock Crusher."
It was going to be the world's most powerful 4-1000A ever
for the ham bands. Band switched. Vacuum Variables. Table
Sharp Looking.. CCS rated...awesome.. etc. For the uninitiated
a 4-1000A (or a 4X1 as the Big Guns call them) is a glass
envelope radial beam tetrode with 1000 watts of juicy plate
dissipation. Capable of full power operation to 110 MHz, these
behemoths of the vacuum tube set are easy to obtain at
flea markets, ruggedly built, and nearly 10 inches tall.
The object was to build a grounded grid five band amplifier
would maximize the 4-1000A's ability to provide 2 to 3
r.m.s. output. The goal turned into an obsession with finding
the Holy Grail of amplifiers. It was eventually to operate on
thru 10 meters and take 20 years to perfect!
Examination of the general tube characteristics will make the
neophyte linear builder salivate with excitement. High plate
voltage is desirable for many reasons. First and foremost is
higher output power. In addition, one would expect reduced
drive requirements, better linearity, and less possibility of
exceeding grid dissipation as long as proper biasing was used.
I was to find that all the above was true and that the tube
can be operated with up to 7,000 volts with only minor
What evolved had an estimated plate resistance of 6000 ohms
based on a plate voltage of 7000 (10% regulation at 1 amp)
with a plate current of 600 ma. at 4000 watts input. The tube
would provide 2200 watts output with 120 watts drive. That's
3500 watts peak output on SSB considering power supply
Not bad for a Rock Crusher! Since the plate dissipation would
be 1700 watts in tune I decided to use a 160cfm blower to
provide required 20-35cfm. I designed the plate tank around a
PIDUX 195-2 and vacuum variables for tuning and loading.
I wanted the amplifier quiet in standby. Vacuum changeover
relays are notoriously leaky so I used a spare set of change-
over relay contacts to ground the amplifier output in standby.
I also provided 110vdc for application to the cathode circuit
to assure that the tube was biased beyond cutoff.
The operating "Q" point bias was derived in a unique way.
The tube requires 5 to 7 volts applied to the cathode circuit
to operate in Class B. Since the grids are GROUNDED (I mean
with heavy bus bar) the bias must be applied as a positive
potential reference to ground to the center tap of the
transformer. The best system I've found is to use a string of
forward biased silicon diodes. The anode end is grounded and
the cathode end is connected to the center tap during
A single pole multi position deck switch is used to adjust the
'Q' point by shunting out unneeded diodes. Each diode drops
1/2 volt so about 12 are used normally to get 6 volts. This
voltage drop occurs whenever plate current flows and the
developed is independent of the current drawn.
It's easy to make these brutes work up to 20 meters but
things happen when that plate tuning capacitor is near minimum
capacity! All of a sudden thump and you pin the plate current
meter and bend the hand, blow out the current reference
blow the power supply fuse (if you have installed one) and
melt the tube plate if you don't shut it down fast enough. You
are the victim of VHF parasitics. Those 813s look pretty
sweet right now! I've tried a whole box full of parasitic
suppressors but the recent articles by Rich Measures AG6K
the subject fully and I will only relate what works for the
'4X1'. The first and most essential step is the use of a
resonant parasitic trap from either filament lug directly to
ground. Optimum parts values are .2uh consisting of 4 turns
of #16 oxidized nichrome wire 1/2 inch diameter 1/2 inch long
in series with a 2.5 to 10 pf mini air variable capacitor.
Using a grid dip meter, determine the plate parasitic
Adjust bandswitch, tuning, and loading for 10 meter operation
with all power off. Look for the dip between 90 and 110 MHz
right under the wire connected to the plate cap. Then unsolder
the parasitic trap coil from the filament lug and solder
to ground. Using the grid dip meter, adjust the parasitic trap
to the same frequency. Reconnect to the coil to the filament
pin disturbing its shape a little as possible. This low 'Q'
trap swamps out the feedback path in the cathode circuit.
#16 nichrome wire was salvaged from a burned out element
in my electric clothes dryer.
The final path to total stability requires an examination of
the anode parasitic suppressor. The 4-1000A at 6000 ohm plate
resistance uses only 14 pf for the plate tuning capacitor in
the plate tank. The 4-1000A output capacitance is about 8pf
leaving only 6pf for the sum of the tuning capacitor and all
stray capacitance. By golly my tuning capacitor is at
minimum and I still can't get it resonant on 30 MHz!
So I reduced the 10 meter tank coil value just enough
to make the circuit resonant on 30 MHz. This hurt the
efficiency somewhat but was a better alternative that reducing
the plate voltage for just one band! The final value was
2.0 uh- 5 turns of flattened 3/8 inch copper tubing, 2 1/4
inches in diameter and 5 inches long, which replaced the
PIDUX supplied 10 meter coil made of strap.
The actual anode suppressor was next. Using the formulas
from Rich Measures' article, I discovered that 4.5 amps
of current was flowing through the anode suppressor and
the tube output capacitance, half of my total on 10 meters!
No wonder my plate efficiency was poor on 30 MHz, the anode
suppressor was a significant part of the tank circuit!
Because of the cathode circuit swamping trap I was able to
reduce the anode parasitic inductance to .04uh and still
maintain total stability. Most of my box full of scrap high
'Q' shiny silver plated parasitic trap inductors were .2uh.
How many 200 watt 100 ohm non-inductive resistors have you
seen in the anode circuits of 4X1 amps? Plenty.
0.2uh (38 ohms at 30 MHz) develops a voltage drop of 170
volts at 30 MHz, forcing 292 watts of 10 meter energy to be
soaked up by that poor parasitic resistor. No wonder they
start smelling bad in tune on 10 M! The final solution was
a 1/2 inch wide 1 inch long hairpin inductor made of #16
nichrome wire clamped to a 50 watt 200 ohm (cold) Globar
resistor. The hairpin inductor is only 0.04uh (7.5 ohms at
30 MHz.) resulting in a 34 volt drop and a resulting 6 watts
dissipated in the Globar on tune. As the Globar heats, its
value falls to 40 ohms thereby increasing its dissipation to
29 watts. The oxidized nichrome is lossy at VHF and its low
'Q' make it effective over a broader frequency range; You
will find that the parasitic frequency varies depending on the
bandswitch and tuning capacitor settings, making lossy
broad banded-ness desirable. The nichrome doesn't help
efficiency on 10 M so some loss in output is experienced.
In fact, power output is reduced from 2200 watts to only 1700
on 10 meters at 44% efficiency.
I finally found a use for that old gray ugly dryer element
It was hard to solder to but judicious scraping and wrapping
some #22 copper onto the connection points "wire wrap" style
seems to have worked. The amplifier is stable under all
WARC band and 160 Meters
WARC band and 160 meter operation provided me with two more
years of fun and nightmares. The most difficult problem was
finding or building a plate RF choke that would not blow up,
roast, melt, or in some other way embarrass its owner on some
band or another. In the beginning I used a B&W 800. Then
there was 12 meters. The B&W 800 has a self resonance at
24.5 MHz and self destructs on 12. The B&W 800 used #28 gauge
wire and had an inductance of 100uh. On 160 M too much current
flows resulting in overheating and those beautiful windings
from elongation and loosen. The coup de grace happens the next
time you tune up on 10 or 15 meters and the coil resonances
I built a delrin core choke of #22 copper. It worked well but
still showed signs of overheating in the 4X1 on 160 M. It was
1 inch away from the chimney but the failure mode was caused
the wire overheating in 160 M contest operation; too much
for its 110 uh. The wire stretched and moved the coil
too close to 20 M. It never exploded but its reactance was so
low on 20 M that some associated plate supply components were
ruined. I even had a small exciting fire one evening. Delrin
will burn if its hot enough!
It was indeed becoming challenging to get this thing to work
all bands. I tried chokes at right angles; unsuccessful.
I tried segmentation; windings arced to each other. I tried
spaced out segmentation schemes; they each ended up with
series resonances in the wrong place. I needed 240uh
and couldn't get it!
Finally, I gave up! I built a two section choke. Each section
is soleniodal; the top section is a modified Ohmite Z7 with
34 turns removed making it 80 uh with a lowest self resonance
at 34 MHz. It consists of #30 wire close wound on a 1/2 inch
diameter ceramic form which is epoxy coated. The modified Z7
is stacked end-to-end on top of a 1 inch diameter 4 inch long
delrin rod with 140 turns of close wound #26 which is
The delrin rod bottom section is 160uh with self resonances at
16.2 and 25.5 Mhz. On 160 and 80M the whole combined choke is
for 240uh with a combined lowest series resonance at 11.5
MHz. On 40 meters a high voltage relay shorts out the bottom
RFC section. Presto- no more trouble.
An extra wafer on the bandswitch shaft is used to provide
ground to operate the relay on 40 M and higher. On 160 and
80 meters the same wafer grounds a 1500 or a 500pf capacitor
on the loading side of the tank, since the 1000 pf of the
loading vacuum variable is insufficient on these bands.
Adding extra tank coil inductance on the end of the PIDUX
195-2 proved to have a few novel surprises also. 20uh
(21 t) of B&W 3033 coil stock was used to provide the extra
inductance for 160 meter operation. The 160 meter conversion
also required the bifilar filament choke core be changed to
an Amidon R33-050-750, doubling its reactance, as well as
construction of appropriate input circuits. The plate
tuning vacuum variable was sufficient for 160, a blessing
of high plate resistance! The amplifier loaded up fine
the first time tried on 160 meters. Success! Well, almost.
No output on 20! The newly formed gigantic plate tank
coil had a titanic flaw, it was self resonant near 15 MHZ.
The tank was so busy soaking up all the r.f. that nothing
could make it to the antenna. Now what? I like 20 Meters.
A brilliant idea struck me. Why not open up the cold end of
tank instead of shunting it out. That should change the
series resonances. It worked! The 15 MHz self resonance moved
to 18 MHz. The amp worked on 160, 80, 40, 20, 15, 12, and 10.
Panacea. I was ecstatic. Then someone came up with 17 meters.
The first time I loaded up on 17 M the open end of the plate
tank coil arced like one of those gadgets in a Frankenstein
movie. 1 inch flames. Not Good. Another brilliant idea
hit me. Lets short the open end of the tank to ground and
try again. 2200 watts on 17 meters happened, but 20 meters
didn't operate. Brute force solution: I built a high voltage
grounding finger that shorts the tank to ground only on 17
meters! All h.f. band operation was a reality. Lets hope
they don't invent any more bands or I'll have to start over
with a roller inductor!
I've been using the 4X1 now for nearly 20 years and have
gained invaluable experience with it. Every year I learn
more about power amplifiers. As you can tell I like to
experiment. It sure is fun to rip a hole in the ionosphere
and tromp all over those puny 3-500Z's in pileups. It's
also fun to hear the horror stories about how someone
melted down his 4CX1200A7 on 12 meters let alone 17 meters....